PS5 Controller vs Xbox Controller UK: Which Should You Buy?

Buy a DualSense if you play on PS5 and an Xbox Wireless Controller if you play on Xbox Series X or S. The DualSense has haptic feedback, adaptive triggers and a built-in battery, while the Xbox pad runs on two AA batteries. At The Tech Gadgets both are pre-owned, tested and cleaned, with a 12-month warranty.

A PS5 controller and an Xbox controller do the same job on different machines, so the choice usually comes down to the console you own. This guide from The Tech Gadgets compares the Sony PlayStation 5 DualSense and the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller on features, compatibility, batteries and charging, and explains what pre-owned means when you buy a spare pad. Both are sold in Pristine Condition: used, then tested and cleaned, not new or sealed.

Quick picks: PS5 controller or Xbox controller

Pick the DualSense if you play on PlayStation 5 and the Xbox Wireless Controller if you play on an Xbox Series X or S. The consoles are here too in case you are buying a pad and a console together.

Key facts

  • Both controllers are pre-owned in Pristine Condition: tested and cleaned, not new or sealed.
  • The DualSense has a built-in rechargeable battery; the Xbox pad runs on two AA batteries.
  • The DualSense listed is the standard model, not the DualSense Edge.
  • Every device has a 12-month warranty from The Tech Gadgets.
  • Order by 3pm Monday to Friday for same-day dispatch from Manchester.
Nintendo Switch OLED Model console

Best for handheld and family play

Nintendo Switch OLED 64GB (pre-owned)

A 7-inch OLED handheld that docks to the TV, for players who do not need 4K.

  • 7-inch OLED screen
  • 64GB, microSD expandable
  • Confirm Joy-Con and cables with the team

from £250

Buy now Add to basket

Adds the Nintendo Switch OLED 64GB (pre-owned) to your basket.

1m braided 60W USB-C to USB-C fast charging cable

Best for a spare charging cable

USB-C to USB-C cable, 1m

A 1m braided USB-C to USB-C cable rated at 60W, for charging USB-C devices.

  • USB-C to USB-C
  • Up to 60W
  • 1m braided

from £5.99

Buy now Add to basket

Adds the USB-C to USB-C cable, 1m to your basket.

The DualSense, the Xbox Wireless Controller, the PS5 and the Xbox Series S are all out of stock right now, so we've listed the Switch OLED and a USB-C charging cable as the closest in-stock alternatives.

Upgrading? Sell us your old phone for store credit

Get an instant quote, post your old phone to us with free tracked postage, and choose store credit to put towards your new phone. Your quote is held for 14 days and your data is wiped securely.

Get a quote for your old phone

PS5 controller vs Xbox controller: side-by-side

The DualSense offers haptic feedback and adaptive triggers with a sealed rechargeable battery, while the Xbox controller offers AA battery power, a Share button and a wider list of compatible devices. This table uses the facts on each product page.

Feature Sony DualSense Xbox Wireless Controller
Condition Pristine Condition, pre-owned Pristine Condition, pre-owned
Made for PS5; also PC, Mac and mobile devices, per Sony Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows 10/11, Android and iOS
Connection Bluetooth, or wired via USB-C Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth, or wired via USB-C
Power Built-in rechargeable battery, charged over USB-C 2 x AA batteries, up to 40 hours per Microsoft
Headset Built-in speaker and headset jack 3.5mm headset jack
Signature features Haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, light bar Share button, hybrid D-pad, textured grips, button mapping in the Xbox Accessories app
Battery wear on a used pad Possible; we do not yet grade controller batteries None, as there is no built-in battery

Which controller works with which console, PC and phone?

Each controller is built for its own console family, so match the pad to the console you own. If you are still deciding between consoles, our guide to the best refurbished gaming console in the UK is a good place to start.

Using a DualSense

The PS5 DualSense is the controller Sony ships with the PS5, so a used PS5 controller of this kind matches the console exactly. A second hand PS5 controller is a safe spare as long as it is the standard model. Sony also says it works with PC, Mac and mobile devices over Bluetooth, and it can be used wired over USB-C. Sony does not list PS4 as compatible, so treat it as a PS5 accessory first.

Using an Xbox controller

The pad listed here is the current model made for Xbox Series X and S. It also works with Xbox One and Windows 10 or 11, and with Android and iOS devices over Bluetooth. It pairs with a console over Xbox Wireless, which makes it easy to share between a console and a PC.

Features that matter: haptics, triggers, share button

The PlayStation DualSense is the more tactile pad and the Xbox controller is the more practical one. Which you prefer comes down to the games you play and how you like to hold a controller.

DualSense features

Sony describes the haptic feedback as responsive vibrations that react to what happens in the game, and the adaptive triggers as giving varying levels of force and tension. Both work in PS5 games that support them. A built-in speaker and a light bar sit alongside, and the headset jack lets you use audio without the TV.

Xbox controller features

Microsoft lists a Share button for screenshots and clips, a hybrid D-pad and textured grips on the triggers, bumpers and back. You can remap buttons through the Xbox Accessories app, and a 3.5mm headset jack handles audio. The Xbox pad is the same controller Microsoft ships with every Series X and S.

Good to know: the listing here is the standard DualSense, not the DualSense Edge. If you want the standard pad, it is the one listed here.

Battery and charging: sealed battery vs AA

The DualSense charges over USB-C from the PS5 or any USB charger, while the Xbox controller takes two AA batteries that Microsoft rates at up to 40 hours. Neither approach is better in every home, so think about how you play.

With the DualSense, a flat pad means plugging in for a while. The battery is sealed, and on a used controller it may last less than on a new one. We do not yet grade controller batteries, so treat battery life as a known trade-off of buying pre-owned. The Xbox controller has no built-in battery, so there is no battery wear to worry about on a pre-owned pad. You can use rechargeable AA cells or Microsoft's Play and Charge Kit, sold separately, if you want to avoid buying disposables.

Please message us before ordering to confirm whether a cable or batteries are included, because we only list what we can confirm.

What pre-owned means for a spare pad

A used PS5 controller or second hand Xbox controller has been played with before, so it is not new. Ours are tested and cleaned before listing, and Pristine Condition means fully working with little or no visible wear. The photo on each page is a product image, not your controller.

A refurbished PS5 controller or refurbished Xbox controller is a working pad for less than new. The label matters less than the terms behind it. Ours include a 12-month warranty from The Tech Gadgets covering faults in normal use, but not accidental damage, liquid damage or repairs by anyone other than us. Your rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 also apply, and our guide to refurbished warranty and consumer rights explains how they fit together.

The trade-offs are normal use: stick and button feel may differ slightly from a new pad, within our Pristine definition. See how we test and grade for how we check stock.

Who should buy which controller?

Buy by console first, then by what you need the pad to do. These pointers cover the most common cases.

  • Second player on PS5: a DualSense. It is the controller Sony ships with the PS5 and suits a spare for couch co-op or a replacement for a worn pad.
  • Second player on Xbox: the Xbox Wireless Controller. It is the same controller Microsoft ships with Series X and S.
  • Xbox player who also uses a PC: the Xbox pad, because it works with Windows 10 and 11.
  • Player who wants adaptive triggers and haptics: the DualSense.
  • Player who dislikes charging: the Xbox pad, with AA batteries you can swap.
  • New console buyer: the PS5 comes with one DualSense. With the Series S, confirm whether a controller is included before you order.

A cheap PS5 controller or cheap Xbox controller is only good value if it has been tested and comes with a warranty, which every pad here does. The Xbox pad costs slightly less than the DualSense, so the Xbox controller price and the PS5 controller price are close enough that features should decide it.

Checks to make when your controller arrives

Test the pad properly in the first few days, while the 14-day right to cancel and 30-day change-of-mind returns still apply to unused, complete items. Work through these steps.

  1. Check the contents against what the team confirmed, including any cable or batteries.
  2. Connect it to your console, then test every button, both sticks and both triggers.
  3. On the DualSense, charge it over USB-C and try the haptics and adaptive triggers in a supported game.
  4. On the Xbox pad, fit AA batteries, pair it over Xbox Wireless and try the Share button and the headset jack.
  5. Look for stick drift, where the character moves without input, and for sticky or unresponsive buttons.
  6. If anything is faulty, contact us so the warranty and the 30-day right to reject under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 can apply.

Order by 3pm UK time Monday to Friday for same-day dispatch from Manchester. Standard delivery takes 1 to 3 working days. See the shipping policy and refund policy for the details.

How to choose before you buy

Choose the pad that matches your console, then check the box contents. This checklist keeps it simple.

  • Which console do you own? PS5 means DualSense, Xbox Series X or S means the Xbox controller.
  • Do you also play on PC or a phone? Both pads connect over Bluetooth.
  • Do you prefer charging or swapping batteries?
  • Planning to buy PS5 controller spares for a second player? Check you are getting the standard DualSense.
  • Planning to buy Xbox controller spares? Confirm with us whether batteries are included.

Final word: which controller should you buy?

Match the pad to your console. The DualSense suits PS5 owners who want haptics and adaptive triggers, and the Xbox controller suits Xbox and PC players who like AA batteries and the Share button. Browse the controllers collection for live stock, or message us on WhatsApp if you want the cable, batteries or colour confirmed first.

Upgrading? Sell us your old phone for store credit

Get an instant quote, post your old phone to us with free tracked postage, and choose store credit to put towards your new phone. Your quote is held for 14 days and your data is wiped securely.

Get a quote for your old phone

Frequently asked questions

Is a used PS5 controller worth buying?

Yes, for a second player or a replacement. A used PS5 controller here is a DualSense that has been tested and cleaned, in Pristine Condition. The trade-offs are battery age and normal wear. We do not yet grade controller batteries, and a 12-month warranty applies.

Can I use a DualSense on PC or a phone?

Sony says the DualSense works with PC, Mac and mobile devices as well as PS5. It connects over Bluetooth or wired via USB-C. Sony does not list PS4 as compatible, so treat it as a PS5 accessory first.

Does the Xbox controller need batteries?

Yes. It runs on two AA batteries, which Microsoft rates at up to 40 hours. It has no built-in rechargeable battery, so there is no battery wear on a pre-owned pad. Message us to confirm whether batteries are included.

Is this the DualSense Edge?

No. The listing is the standard DualSense wireless controller, not the DualSense Edge. It has haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, a built-in speaker and a light bar, and a built-in rechargeable battery that charges over USB-C.

What does Pristine Condition mean for a second hand Xbox controller?

It is our label for pre-owned stock. The controller has been used before, so it is not new or sealed. We test and clean it before listing, and it is fully working with little or no visible wear.

Can I return a controller if I change my mind?

Yes. Unused, complete items can be returned within 30 days and you pay the return postage. You also have a 14-day legal right to cancel an online order. Faulty items are covered by the 12-month warranty and the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

Shop the products in this guide

Back to blog